2010-11: McCulley took a redshirt during his first season with the UW program, as he wrestled in five open tournaments at 157 pounds. He posted a 23-5 overall record, including 4-4 against the WWC, with eight pins and three major decisions.
McCulley started 2010-11 with a title at the Northwest Open, but just missed placing at the Cowboy Open. He rebounded to claim third in his last three tournaments of the season. He notched a combined 16-3 mark to finish third at the UNK Loper Open, Utah Valley Open and Rocky Mountain Open.
High School: At Rock Springs High School, McCulley was the Wyoming 4A State Champion in 2008 at 130 pounds as a sophomore and then again in 2010 as a senior at 152 pounds. As a junior in 2009, he was injured at the state tournament competing at 145 pounds.
McCulley is a three-time 4A West Regional Champion. In 2008 he was the Wyoming USA Wrestling Triple Crown winner, as well as a Cadet All-American by placing fourth at USA Wrestling Nationals.
McCulley was on the honor roll each year at Rock Springs H.S.
Personal: Andy is one of two sons of Mark and Nikki McCulley. He was born on May 7, 1992. His younger brother's name is Zachary. His grandfather, father and two uncles all wrestled at the collegiate level. Andy is an elementary education major at UW.